Review & agreed-upon procedures
Review & Agreed-Upon Procedures are two professional accounting services that help businesses obtain valuable insights into their financial information. Although both involve the work of an independent accounting professional, they have different objectives, procedures, and reporting outcomes. Understanding these differences helps business owners choose the appropriate service for their financial and operational needs.
Companies in Saudi Arabia may use these services to improve financial transparency, support management decisions, meet stakeholder requirements, or examine specific financial matters.
What Is a Review Engagement?
A review engagement is a professional service in which an independent accountant performs procedures to obtain limited assurance about whether financial statements are free from material misstatement.
Unlike an external audit, a review does not involve extensive testing of transactions, internal controls, and supporting documents. Instead, the accountant primarily uses inquiries, analytical procedures, and other appropriate review methods.
The objective is to determine whether anything has come to the accountant’s attention that suggests the financial statements may not be prepared, in all material respects, in accordance with the applicable financial reporting framework.
Key Characteristics of a Review
A review engagement generally includes:
- Examining financial information and identifying unusual movements.
- Making inquiries with management about accounting policies and significant transactions.
- Comparing current financial results with previous periods.
- Analyzing relationships between financial statement figures.
- Issuing a review report based on the procedures performed.
A review provides limited assurance, which is lower than the reasonable assurance provided by an audit.
What Are Agreed-Upon Procedures?
Agreed-Upon Procedures, commonly known as AUP, are professional engagements in which an accountant performs specific procedures that have been agreed upon with the engaging party and other intended users.
The accountant reports the factual findings resulting from those procedures. The engagement does not provide an audit opinion or a review conclusion.
The procedures are designed around the particular information or financial areas that users want to examine.
For example, a company may request agreed-upon procedures to verify selected supplier balances, examine specific expenses, check inventory records, or compare financial transactions with supporting documents.
Common Examples of Agreed-Upon Procedures
Businesses may request AUP engagements for several purposes, including:
- Checking selected revenue transactions against invoices.
- Comparing supplier statements with accounting records.
- Examining specific payroll calculations.
- Verifying selected inventory quantities.
- Reviewing supporting documents for particular expenses.
- Checking compliance with specific contractual requirements.
The final report describes the procedures performed and the factual findings identified. Users evaluate those findings and decide what conclusions are appropriate for their circumstances.
Review vs. Agreed-Upon Procedures: Main Differences
Although both services involve independent professional work, they are not interchangeable.
| Comparison | Review Engagement | Agreed-Upon Procedures |
|---|---|---|
| Main objective | Provide limited assurance | Report factual findings |
| Scope | Financial statements | Specific agreed areas |
| Procedures | Inquiries and analytical procedures | Procedures agreed with intended users |
| Assurance | Limited assurance | No assurance |
| Report | Review conclusion | Findings report |
| Flexibility | Based on review standards | Tailored to agreed procedures |
The most important difference is the final outcome. A review provides limited assurance on financial statements, while agreed-upon procedures provide factual findings without an assurance conclusion.
When Should a Business Choose a Review?
A review engagement may be appropriate when management, owners, lenders, or other stakeholders need an independent examination of financial statements but do not require a full external audit.
It can be useful for businesses that want additional confidence in their financial reporting, identify unusual financial trends, or provide stakeholders with an independent review conclusion.
The appropriate engagement depends on applicable regulations, contractual obligations, and the needs of the intended users.
When Are Agreed-Upon Procedures More Suitable?
Agreed-upon procedures may be more suitable when a business needs specific financial information examined rather than its entire set of financial statements.
For example, a company involved in a commercial transaction may want an accountant to examine selected balances or supporting documents. Similarly, management may request procedures to investigate particular expenses or verify certain financial records.
Because the scope is agreed in advance, the engagement can focus on clearly defined questions and deliver factual results.
Choosing the Right Accounting Service in Saudi Arabia
Businesses in Saudi Arabia should consider their objectives, reporting requirements, and stakeholder expectations before selecting either service.
A professional accounting firm can help determine whether a review engagement or agreed-upon procedures engagement is appropriate. The firm should clearly explain the scope, responsibilities, applicable professional standards, and expected reporting format before starting the work.
It is also important to confirm whether the requested service satisfies any relevant regulatory or contractual requirements. AUP should not be treated as a replacement for an audit or review when those engagements are specifically required.
Conclusion
Review & Agreed-Upon Procedures serve different purposes in financial reporting. A review provides limited assurance on financial statements, while agreed-upon procedures deliver factual findings from specifically agreed procedures.
Selecting the right service helps businesses obtain relevant financial information, improve transparency, and make better-informed decisions. Working with an experienced accounting professional ensures that the engagement is properly defined and aligned with the company’s requirements.